Dive Brief:
- Nippon Dynawave Packaging has been fined $10.1 million for violations related to the white liquor tank implosion at its Longview mill on May 26 that killed 11 people and injured 12 others. The bulk is from the Washington State Department of Labor & Industries, which on Friday cited NDP for 75 safety violations worth nearly $9.2 million in fines. The Department of Ecology issued $961,000 in penalties for environmental violations and recovery costs.
- L&I released an accompanying report following its six-month investigation into the incident. It concluded that NDP was aware at least since August 2025 that the tank walls were “dangerously” thin, yet it continued to use the equipment for 43 weeks without making repairs or altering operations.
- L&I will refer the case to prosecutors for potential criminal charges because the “safety and health violations were both willful and contributed directly to the deaths of its workers.” The state’s attorney general’s office announced in July it would investigate whether criminal behavior contributed to the disaster.
Dive Insight:
L&I said in a news release Friday that the NDP incident was “the worst industrial disaster in modern state history.”
"Given the severity, this is the largest workplace safety and health penalty in the state's history," said Joel Sacks, L&I director, during a news conference Friday. He noted that even at the federal level, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration has only issued penalties worth more than $9 million at three points in its history.
The tank failure caused the release of 900,000 gallons of scalding white liquor. “At that volume, the pressure was more than 200% the stress capacity,” according to L&I’s report.
L&I also concluded in the report that NDP “missed or ignored inspections at dozens of other tanks” on site and that its emergency planning and response “fell well short of the requirements outlined in state rules.” It said the company did not have an employer-led incident command, failed to sufficiently brief first responders, failed to set up an effective boundary around the tank spill, and didn’t “[c]ommunicate with other employers on the same property about what was happening.”
L&I said in the release that NDP has racked up a total of more than $10 million in penalties and cost recovery from state agencies due to “[d]ozens of violations related to that tank, other tanks on the site, the company’s emergency response, and the environmental impact.” Money collected from fines goes to the workers’ compensation supplemental pension fund, helping workers and families of those who died on the job.
In August, the Washington Department of Ecology cited NDP for 35 environmental violations related to the tank implosion. That same week, L&I cited the company for a safety incident that preceded, and was unrelated to, the tank implosion; it issued a second, similar citation Oct. 29. L&I said Friday that there are two inspections ongoing at the Longview mill, unrelated to the tank implosion, and citations for those are due by December.
In the months after the NDP disaster, L&I had announced inspections at the state’s two other kraft pulp and paper mills, owned by Smurfit Westrock and Port Townsend Paper Co., and seven non-kraft mills to “make sure the issues at Nippon Dynawave are not widespread at other paper mills.” L&I will release the results of those inspections in February 2027.
NDP has 15 working days to appeal the citations L&I issued today. It also must fix the hazards identified in the citations, including to “[r]ebuild, reduce capacity on, or drain tanks where engineers or contracted inspectors found deficiencies.” The company also is required to immediately post the citation notice where employees can read it for seven working days or until all violations are corrected, whichever is longer.
Of the 75 violations, 64 are listed as “egregious willful serious,” which is the highest level. “The employer did not provide employees a workplace free from recognized hazards,” the citation says repeatedly when describing numerous violations.
The report shows that employees had raised concerns about the tank’s safety and had inquired about fixes. An email from a management employee dated Sept. 8, 2025, said: "This doesn't look good. Should we take this tank out of service for an internal repair ASAP? Run the level lower for now? I'm looking for suggestions..."
In a Nov. 18 news release, NDP acknowledged that L&I is required by law to issue a workplace safety report within 180 days of an incident. “A workplace-safety report and a completed root-cause investigation serve different purposes,” the company said. “Any report issued before the tank examination and forensic analysis concludes should be understood in that context.”
NDP said the tank “is currently being deconstructed, with great care being taken to log and retain portions of the tank to determine the root cause,” and it anticipates deconstruction will be complete in December. In the first quarter of 2027, the company expects further site investigation, examination of the tank and component parts, and laboratory analysis and testing. It expects a root cause analysis to be completed in spring or summer 2027.
The federal U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board provided a preliminary report in August suggesting NDP was aware of safety concerns with its tank wall prior to the implosion. CSB expects to release its final report in spring 2027. CSB is an independent, nonregulatory federal agency and does not issue citations or penalties; L&I is the main enforcement authority for the NDP site.
NDP said at the time that the CSB update “failed to include important facts and context regarding actions taken by NDP and the timeline of events before the May 26 incident.
In its Wednesday news release, NDP reiterated its “disappointment with investigative updates and press releases that precede critical evidence examination or root cause analysis, and include characterizations of preliminary information as an established explanation of the incident.”
The mill has remained largely shut down since the May incident. Earlier this month, parent company Nippon Paper announced its intention to restart the mill in December. Most of the employees were slated to return in October.
NDP announced on Nov. 2 that its president, Matt Peerboom, would retire the next day after having postponed his retirement plans due to the May incident. On Nov. 13 the company said Brian Wood, who was director of support services, would become president as of Nov. 16.