Dive Brief:
- Packaging industry groups that filed a lawsuit in March to challenge California’s SB 343, the state’s “truth in labeling” law, amended the complaint on Thursday to also include SB 54, the state’s EPR for packaging law. The case was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California.
- The complaint alleges that SB 54 uses the same broad definition of “recyclable” as SB 343. The lawsuit also alleges that SB 54 doesn’t adequately define “nonrecyclable” or “less likely to be recycled” in regards to source reduction, nor does it establish a clear compliance standard.
- The plaintiffs request injunctive relief to halt SB 54 enforcement. SB 343 initially was set to take effect Oct. 4, but in July a federal judge granted a preliminary injunction to block full enforcement.
Dive Insight:
The Flexible Packaging Association, the American Forest & Paper Association, and the Consumer Brands Association are among the more than 20 national and regional groups to bring this lawsuit. Defendants include California Attorney General Rob Bonta, CalRecycle Director Zoe Heller and Director of the Department of Tax and Fee Administration Trista Woessner-Gonzalez.
FPA did not respond to a request for comment by publication time. AF&PA referenced a statement it put out Oct. 9 about seeking to add challenges regarding SB 54.
“California’s SB 54 gets paper wrong. It treats widely recycled paper and paper-based packaging like materials that face fundamentally different recycling challenges, imposing new costs without improving paper recycling,” said AF&PA Vice President of Government Affairs Julie Landry in the statement. The group said effective policy should “recognize the important differences among materials,” but “instead, SB 54 risks increasing costs, disrupting established recycling markets and creating uncertainty for manufacturers and consumers.”
The lawsuit is not intended to “undermine” SB 54’s packaging recyclability requirements, according to the complaint. Rather, it is meant “to challenge discrete implementation failures that defeat rather than advance those shared objectives” and allegedly unfairly burden member companies.
“These requirements place enormous logistical burdens on businesses that must remain in a constant state of vigilance lest their products and packaging no longer be compliant with the relevant recyclability and recycling thresholds,” the complaint says. “Businesses that cannot navigate the unclear and mercurial standards of SB 54 are faced with a choice: risk the credible and onerous threat of civil penalties and other liabilities, or withdraw their products from the California marketplace.”
California’s SB 343, which set specific thresholds for when packaging can be labeled recyclable, has threatened the status of certain types of products in the market and spurred ongoing industry reaction.
The lawsuit also challenges aspects of SB 54’s funding structure. It says that producer responsibility organization Circular Action Alliance’s most recent draft program plan, from Oct. 13, shows that the number of producers registered is “dramatically below CalRecycle’s projections” of “several thousand” participants.
CAA’s updated plan says more than 4,000 producers were registered as of October. It lowered budget projections, which initially were a range between $9.4 billion to $17.2 billion for the five-year plan. They now stand at $7.81 billion to $13.1 billion. That decline is partially due to drops in projected program reserves, capital and operating costs for collection and compost, and reuse and refill-related costs, according to CAA.
“Defendants continue to enforce obligations on the PRO that require billions of dollars of funding from producers” that are based on questionable projections, the complaint says, “without adequately explaining the discrepancy or addressing the resulting inequities imposed on those producers who have complied with their obligation to timely register.”
Therefore, the plaintiffs request “injunctive relief to prevent enforcement of SB 54’s obligations on the PRO that require funding from producers.”
Court documents for the updated case reference at least three other lawsuits that are playing out over SB 54.
Most notably, the National Association of Wholesaler-Distributors joined attorneys general from 17 states in a June challenge of SB 54, claiming “unprecedented overreach.” Meanwhile, NAW is appealing a judge’s ruling from July that upheld Oregon’s EPR for packaging law, saying it’s not unconstitutional as NAW claimed.